Thursday, July 12, 2012

A primer on Vedic/Hindu scripturology for the reference of skeptics - Part I


Most Hindus and especially those who occupy higher echelons of the caste and class hierarchy of the Hindu society, mostly in India, as also in some western nations with a significant Hindu Diaspora, take great and almost fanatical pride in their scriptures or guide-books of their religion.  

When I mentioned most Hindus, I implied the ones that were not destitute, sorely underprivileged, neglected, condemned and ostracized by the mainstream Hindu society, which ones run into many millions and are called sudras, dalits, scheduled castes and other such names and classifications. 

The opinion leaders of Hinduism, its defenders and apologists exist and thrive in the mainstream, middle-class and upper crust of the Hindu society and are the most vocal votaries and adherents of the Vedic and post-Vedic Hindu scriptures. 

This part of the Hindu society consists of the Brahmins, Kshatriyas and the Vaisyas along with their innumerable castes, sub-castes, sects and groupings. While there is a caste-based hierarchy and class gradations within these three large Hindu castes, with their own contentions, disputes, jealousies and animosities, they have over the centuries made some peace among themselves at the expense of the fourth and the most populous caste or group, the sudras/dalits, relegating them to civilizational darkness and oblivion.

While Brahmins have mostly authored the Vedic/Hindu scriptures, the Kshatriyas and Vaisyas too have benefited from its canons, sacraments and edicts, though not to the same extent and degree as the super-caste of the Brahmins. But these scriptures through their evolution have bestowed many benefits on these two to the complete exclusion and isolation of the Sudras/Dalits. So when Brahmin intelligentsia glorifies these scriptures, Kshatriyas and Vaisyas are not far behind in their approval, applause and emulation. 

Effectively the sizable literate and privileged part of the Hindu society made up of the three upper castes or dwijas (twice-born) of Brahmins,  Kshatriyas and Vaisyas, though an overall minority, represent the visible and articulate face of Hindu mainstream society the world over.

On the 'broad' shoulders of this part of the elitist Hindu society, rests the burden of the claims of the so-called excellence, greatness, eternity, purity and sublimity of these impugned scriptures. And they leave no stone unturned in singing and preaching its ‘eternal’ glory to their choir and beyond. 

Just like any other social class, the Hindus also make a big deal of their scriptures. But what are these scriptures, what do they consist of and how well and what do Hindus know about their own scriptures are questions that need to be looked into deeply and critically.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Rangnath,

    I just wrote a small piece on Mahabharata. Check it out.

    http://gurpreetsumra.blogspot.ca/2012/08/mahabharata-document-of-prostitution.html

    Gurpreet

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gurpreet,

    As I mentioned in my comment to your review on VR Narla, I owe you this one too


    Will surely read it and get back with my comments

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have not met any Hindu in my lifetime who "take great and almost fanatical pride in their scriptures or guide-books of their religion". In fact I hardly know any person who has true or any knowledge on these books.

    You are suffering from some disease.

    By the way, I would like to know your opinions on other religions as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Raj

      Just because you have not met Hindus who proudly tout their scriptures as the greatest in the world and react violently to its criticism or questioning (not in terms of physical violence)does not mean that they don't exist in this world. I have come across a few of them during my visits to Chinmaya Mission in US.

      There are also such fanatics in the blogosphere and in email chains that I keep receiving from my relatives. Some of my own relatives can be termed as stout Hindu rightists.

      You cannot know any person who has true or any knowledge on these books because no such great knowledge exists in these books and scriptures. Fantasies, voodoo and mystical mumbo-jumbo do not constitute knowledge.

      I have the same poor opinion about other major religions that I have about Hinduism, not that it is help you in the disease of intolerance and indecency that you are terribly afflicted with.

      Delete